Renaissance Ruminations

A smorgasbord of erratic thoughts on parenting, politics, grilling, marriage, public speaking-all the things that make life interesting.

Archive for the 'Blogroll' Category


Presenting: The Fall 2007 Virginia Blogosphere Book Fair, Part I

Posted by bwana on October 17, 2007

Today we begin the 2007 Virginia Blogosphere Book Fair!

The first version of the Book Fair will be by subject, and w/in the next week the second iteration which will be by blogger!

Biography 

Cicero: The Life and Times of Rome’s Greatest Politician by Anthony Everitt

The Life and Selected Writings of Thomas Jefferson by Thomas Jefferson; Adrienne Koch and William Peden, Editors

 The Seven Storey Mountain by Thomas Merton

Children

My Side of the Mountain by Jean Craighead George

Communication

Made to Stick: Why Some Ideas Survive and Others Die by Chip Heath and Dan Heath

Words that Work: It’s not What You Say, It’s What People Hear by Frank Luntz 

 Current Events

Infidel by Ayann Hirsi Ali

Legacy of Ashes by Tim Weiner

Canary in the Coal Mine by Jessalyn Radack

The Assault on Reason by Al Gore

The People’s Machine: Arnold Schwarzenegger And the Rise of Blockbuster Democracy by Joe Matthews

Future Events(!)

“The Singularity Is Near”by Ray Kurzweil

History

James Madison and the Struggle for the Bill of Rights (Pivotal Moments in American History)by Richard Labunski (Author)

The Savage Wars of Peace: Small Wars and the Rise of American Power by Max Boot

 

Literature and Fiction

“A Lesson Before Dying” by Ernest J. Gaines.

Rosetta 6.2 by James A. Bowden

Nature

 Desert Solitaire by Edward Abbey

National Geographic: The Ultimate Field Guide to Photography (Paperback) by Bob Martin (and others).

Philosophy

Meditations by Sister Wendy

Rosetta 6.2By James A. Bowden

Illusions by Richard Bach 

I apologize for the delay in presenting the results, but a tumble down the front stairs of my house put Bwana on the Beach for a few days. Plus, since the response rate was less than I hoped for I decided to wait for a few days before posting the list…however, I tend to think the diminished response from last year is found in the comment submitted by Bruce Roemmelt and echoed (to some degree) by The Cooch:

“My reading for the past year and next (x) days is limited to walk sheets and call sheets.”

Understood, and good luck!

Yes, I know there is a title that is listed in two sections…but I couldn’t come down on which single topic to add it under, so it gets double billing.

Feel free to add additional titles in the comment section or email them to me at renaissaisancerumiations@hotmail.com

Posted in Blogroll, Books, Communications, Community | 3 Comments »

Truth, VT, and Blogosphere Reprehensibility

Posted by bwana on August 29, 2007

I had planned to do something fun this AM, but a post at NLS got me onto a different path, but one well trod.  Yep, this AM I am all about the ethical use of the internet.

NLS notes that a GOP campaign operative and long time Alton Foley writes that during the Virginia Tech massacre students just got up, lined up against a wall, and waited to be shot. Ben goes on to take Foley’s state senate candidate to task for hiring such a person.

Given that I had heard no such claim before, I sent to Alton’s joint to see his post. Alton goes on to say he knows he will be called “reprehensible” for broaching the subject, and links to the site Media Matters, where it is noted that several commentators asked why students did not rush the gunman. However, the discussion seems to be driven in great part by postings by Neil Boortz, of whom I was blissfully unaware until a few minutes ago.

In his April 17 program notes, cited in the Media Matters piece, Boortz asks:

How in the hell do you line students up against a wall (if that’s the way it played out) and start picking them off one by one without the students turning on you? You have a choice.

Special Emphasis-“if that’s the way it played out”A whole attack on murdered students based on factless speculation?

 Now we get to the root of all this, and of something that is so dangerous about blogs…because they are only as valid as the author’s integrity allows them to be.

Boortz’s first comment, and one that has pushed others, was speculation…and wild, irresponsible speculation at that. I have neither seen nor heard of any report that said students willingly lined up for execution.  His irresponsible speculation was yanked out of the muck within a day of the incident, without complete documentation of what truly happened and in complete disregard for the facts that were in hand…and many jumped onto his speculation without considering anything like…oh, say…facts.

The facts are that there was bravery to spare the terrible morning in Blacksburg, and it has been recounted at length in a variety of media outlets.  Did the students rise up en masse and attack Cho?  Apparently not.  On the other hand, given that the very human instinct to freeze and and assess when confronted with danger, I don’t think the lack of such an attack is proof of the wussification of America.  Of course, given the vitriol spewed, I ponder what would Boortz and Malkin and the rest have done in a similar situation.

But that is fodder for another feeding time.  My concern, and what i think really reprehensible here, is that so many folks accepted he Boortzian speculation as fact without checking the facts themselves…and then, long after the truth was evident, did not go back and and state they were wrong in the first place. Alton wrote:

But these reports of students willingly lining up against a wall disturb me. They should disturb you as well.

What disturbs me is a rush to judgement. What disturbs me is accepting fact as speculation. Of course the irony here is that Alton blindly accepted Boortz’s claims seems without checking facts seems to be as docile and as sheeplike as that he accused the VT students of doing.

But that is the nature of the blogosphere. Posts are only bounded by the integrity and industriousness of the blogger. If a blogger decides to write things that are not true, there will be some folks who will say “it must be true, it’s on the internet”, and accept a falsehood as truth.  Boortz threw out some trash, and then others eagerly jumped on to claim it as their own.

The ability to quickly transmit news and opinion over the internet, as well as conduct commerce, is an electronic miracle.  This from a man who was on the technology cutting edge in college because he had an electronic typewriter with an erasing tape feature. 

But the miracle brings responsibilities as well as benefits.

It is the luxury of blogs to speculate, but speculation needs to identified as such.  Bloggers, and other writers, need to be sure of their facts.  They need to be sure of their sources.  And, if they bite on the wrong hook, they need to ‘fess up in the same forum in which they offered the misstatement.  To not do so is truly irresponsible and wrong.

And that is why I take issue with Alton’s post, and consider it an example of the dangers of the blogosphere.

I have no problem with him taking a controversial position.  Free speech gives him that right, and any community is kept intellectually strong through vigorous debate of topics pleasant or not.

I have a big problem with him taking a controversial position that is based in no fact at all, for blindly following speculation without researching the facts, and then…some months later…still not coming back and correcting the original post.

That is a danger of the blogosphere, and that is why I find Alton’s post reprehensible.

Posted in Blogging, Blogroll, Ethics | 3 Comments »

Bwana at 250-A View from My Keyboard

Posted by bwana on February 23, 2007

This marks my 250th blog posting. I moved from itinerant to semi-regular blogger, I left the nightmare of Blogger for the safe pool of WordPress, and apparently more folks than my immediate family typically take a gander at my posts. Things have changed, and I thought I would take this time to ruminate about the blogosphere…because the more things have changed, the more they have stayed the same.

Blogs still stand as outposts in the cyberworld where anyone can state their opinion on any subject they want. One can rail, rant, and bay at the moon. One can post everything from pictures to political positions and everything in between.

There have been many changes. The world is much more aware of blogs, especially in the political forum. Blogs have become a handy way for organizations to have a website without having an official website. More folks are blogging, with a wide variety of businesses including blogs as part of their customer/user feedback process

There are numerous new factors driving blogs faster and with more velocity than ever before, but I will just touch on a few: immediacy, anonimity, unity, and money.

The immediacy has always been there…after all, what is the point of an online journal if not to share thoughts quickly with the world? But the blogs are now a recognized fast response medium. From the bloggers who took issue with Dan Rather and his GWB National Guard report to George Allen’s Macaca Moment we have seen blogs provide a way to get information to support attacks and coutner-attacks up quickly. They also provide a way to spread the word of the “inside baseball” that goes on within any realm of activity…and that is especially true about Virginia politics, where we have an election every year.

Well…duh, you might say. So what else is new?

What is new is that at the same time that the public is coming to terms with the ability of blogs to pump out information fast, the MSM media is cutting back. The MSM is trying to save money, and is cutting lose reporters left and right. The WaPo had a couple of well publicized cuts, and we fans of NBC-4 in DC have seen several familiar and favorite figures leave as the National Broadcasting System moved to NBC 2.0. Result? While there may be as many talking heads on TV, there are fewer human assets under the corporate umbrella providing news. They are losing not only reporters, but also the network of contacts that reporter has built.

The MSM needs to be able to go somewhere to generate leads and ideas…and that is where Blogs come in.

Your typical MSM reporter can now speed click though the web, find some blogs that cover his subject matters/area…you know, like-say-Virginia Politics…and keep an eye on them for leads. It is quick, easy, and cheap.

That doesn’t mean it works…

Example-in the Virgina 10th Congressional district last fall the blogs and the MSM followed each other around on the same track, noting that Judy Feder was raising a bazillion dollars, that the 10th district demographics were changing, and look at that non-partisan poll that had Frank Wolf leading by only 47-42. Apparently wanting to be able to say they had been the first to say they saw an upset, bloggers and MSM refused to listen to suggestions that the poll had over sampled democrats, that Wolf had plenty of money, that folks were hapyy with the job he was doing. Instead, the term “stealth campaign” was used to refer to a supposedly somnolent Wolf campaign.

So the MSM and bloggers followed each other round and round about the competitve Virginia 10th district congressional race. Imagine their surprise when Judy Feder was blown out of the water by over 16%.

MSM cuts will mean a greater use of blogs to generate new leads and find current “information. How accurate those leads are depends on the judgement and research of the blogger…so I imagine it will be a much used, albeit risky, new source.

Anonimity, or lack of verifiability, is a terrible issue in many forms across the internet. The issue arises everywhere from chat rooms to MySpace…is the person you are communicating with really who/what they say they are? Anonimity will continue to drive the blog world…which is sort of sad. Bloggers like me will adopt pseudonyms. Some will do so to avoid identification due to work or political issues.

Those like me will do it to protect their privacy and potentially their family. I still shudder that the BVBL/Greg Letieq-Daily Whackjob/Greg Bouchillon throwdown of last spring and the vicious postings that followed.

But at least pseudonyms allow an ideological identity to be established and create a degree of responsibility. I have no idea who “t” is, but if postings count then I can say with some confidence that he/she is a devoted pro-life advocate. If someone posts as “t” and makes a claim that is contrary to the profile “t” has built, the poseur poster will quickly be denounced.

Unfortunately, many posters simply use anonymity to spit fire and brimstone.

A prime example came last November when Commonwealth Conservative went dark. Chad Dotson made the announcement a week or so after the 2006 elections that he was closing up due to increasing job pressures plus the need to run for reelection. The closing was mentioned in several blogs, including Not Larry Sabato…where the anonymous dogs began to bay and call him a “loser” and implied he is a hypocrite. Not one of the blogosphere’s happier moments.

The tone of a blog is set by the blogger, and posters follow suit. However, that is not the way it always is, and…unfortunately…that is the way it will continue to be…I doubt the bushwhack brigade will be decamping anytime soon. Conaway Haskins proposed the idea of “Society of Bloggers” to set standards by which blogs would be conducted. The aside has much to say for it beyond a hot acronym. The problem is typically not the bloggers-although it would be good if were always on our best behavior-it’s the posters who use anonimity as a shield to say whatever they want without any sense of decorum or constraint.

Unity-for lack of a better word-is coming at us fast. While it is not a tsunami, and will not submerge the independent blogger, I predict we will see more blogs like Raising Kaine which is really less a blog than an umbrella “community” that allows for multiple people to blogger without having to arrange the contributor type arrangement seen at Republitarian, Bearing Point, and Tooconservative (to name a few). Of course, this can put the lead dog on the blog in a bit of an embarassing position if one of his diarists posts something the lead dog doesn’t like…C’est la vie, c’est la guerre, c’est la pomme de terre.

These communities create a synergy amoung the diarists/posters…it also provides one stop shopping for the MSM types searching for information!

I think the Unified Blog-be it a Community effort or a joint contributor arrangment-will be seen more and more in the future. Why? The combining of information, the thrill of finding like minded people to work with, and the fact that quality blogging is like work. It may be work you enjoy, it may be work you are passionate about, but writing a quality blog piece (at least for we mere mortals) requires time, concentration, editing, and attention to detail…not what you normally find in a hobby. The time involved may not be worth it, the time involved may not be available, or professional considerations may argue against it. Look on the left side of this blog, and see the Blog Boot Hill section. All quality blogs that have gone dark because of time issues…Chad and work, Norm and burn out (although now reborn at Bearing Drift) Bucky in the Mineshaft, Conaway works with Webb, and the long lamented much missed Sic Semper Tyrannis….all matters of time and burnout.

This does not mean we will lose solo practicioners, but it does mean that the group efforts-no matter the format or partisan standing-will become more prevalent.

Then there is the matter of money, greenbacks, coin of the realm. It surprises folks to see there is money in blogging, but more and more there is. Whether it is on staff for a candidate or posting advertisements on the blog there is some money to be made. Unfortunately, advertising means you need to pull in viewers. Viewers mean you have to provide a hook to get them there. Too often this means sensationalism, or borderline misrepresentation of facts.

Advertising also gives some degree of power to the big volume blogs. They have the traffic to drive folks to other blogs through links and recommendations, which means they can positively impact another blogs bottom line. While I don’t have ads, something that happened here last month is a point in case.

On January 11th I posted a lengthy piece on Jim Gilmore. It was something that was rattling around in my head for some time, took a couple of drafts, and came in at over 2500 words. It started to get some attention, still gets hit each week, and is arguably the second most viewed piece I have posted.

On January 15th I posted a piece on something stupid said by David Albo that I noted in an article in the Washington Post. This little oh-by-the-way piece ended up getting over 500 views over the next two days.

The difference? Ben Tribbett linked to the second one on NLS…and the deluge of link clickers was immense.

The presence of some degree of money may impact how the blogs deal with each other. For instance, will a high volume GOP blog be willing to link to pieces by a high volume democratic blogger they despise just to make money? Hard to say, but the presence of money will start to play a role in considerations.

The list of things that have changed is much longer than this, but prudence, aching fingers and a smoking keyboard suggest I cease and post.

I will say as I pass the 250 mark that this whole blogging thing has been a blast, and I have no doubt it will continue to be…and to that end I will offer a few partiing thoughts to:

My beloved SWMBO-Thank you for getting me going on this blog thing…
Chad Dotson-Thanks for CC, congrats on the judgeship, and I hope to meet you some day.
Norm L-Welcome back to your new home at The Drift
Ben Tribbett-You are the best number cruncher in the Virginia blogosphere. You and Kenton Ngo should self publish a statistical analysis of Virginia politics…Between your analysis and his graphics it could go large.
The Folks at Raising Kaine-I disagree with the vast majority of stuff you post, but your site sets the standard for effective political blogging in Virginia and across the country…regardless of what Kos says!
Conaway, Not Buck Turgidson, the crew at Sic Semper Tyrannis-Happy Trails, and I hope we see you back!
Waldo-Your aggregator-repeat, YOUR aggregator-is a great tool and has revolutionized how much impact blogs can have.
Republitarian-Don’t worry, my stuff is coming soon!
BVBL-Don’t change one thing
James Young-Same thing
Jim Hoeft-You have the finest conservative blog in the state-keep it up!
Barnie Day and James Atticus Bowden-One day I hope I write half as well as you guys.
Anke Cheney-Thank you for keeping us all in line…and finally..
Vivian Paige-Not much to say beyond you are “Simply the Best”

Be good, post often, and I better get started on post #251.

Posted in Blogging, Blogroll | 15 Comments »

and another…

Posted by bwana on January 4, 2007

Conaway Haskins has accepted a position with Senator Jim Webb-Congratuations!

Unfortunately, this move means he will be closing down South of the James…and yet another talented voice leaves the Virginia blogosphere…

Posted in Blogging, Blogroll | 1 Comment »

Another One Bites the Dust…

Posted by bwana on January 2, 2007

Apparently One Man’s Trash gets to move Bloggers Boot Hill…Norm is pulling in his shingle.

Posted in Blogging, Blogroll | No Comments »