Va 1: Mom’s Advice, Shenanigans, and a cautionary tale

Tonight and tomorrow night GOP mass meetings throughout Virginia’s First District will select delegates to the District convention on November 10.

I have a favor to ask of you good people.  As you go through the stresses of these meetings, being held right after a general election where some people you know got the short end of the vote, I ask you to remember my late mother’s advice whenever I went to visit someone: “Be nice, and follow the rules”.

I say this as early reports from Caroline County make it seem like some folks may be ignoring both these concepts…consider, for instance, this report:

“…[former] Delegate Dick Black…informed us about the shocking shenanigans that are going on in the First Congressional District. The problems are coming up in the secretive and often difficult process that is being used in selecting the delegates for the convention.

On November 3rd, Del. Black attended one in Caroline County. It was at an unmarked location down a gravel road in the woods. A steel gate marked with “No Trespassing” signs blocked the road. The meeting was scheduled for 9:00 am, but they secretly held it an hour early and you couldn’t enter the meeting without violating the Virginia Code on criminal trespass.

They elected nine delegates for Del. Rob Whitman, who avoided the meeting even though it was in his own district.

It gets even stranger: when Paul Jost, another candidate, showed up and asked why the meeting was held early, a woman helping to run the meeting apparently yelled at him using profanities and she had to be restrained!”

There has been no mention of these events in the press, likely because of the recently held general election.  But let’s just suppose it’s true, or even partially true.  We will even put aside the thought that if this the type of thing that did happen, then the results of this meeting can be thrown out.  Instead, let’s consider that this is the kind of stupid politics that makes conventions tinder boxes for electoral disaster because of the way it can turn off the party faithful and cost a campaign volunteers, financial support, and general good will.

Consider two recent scenarios:

1) Two candidates, hard fought nominating campaign for a House of Delegates nomination.  No chicanery, no fancy footwork on the meeting notice or site.  Room packed with folks.  Candidate A has more bodies, but Candidate B has more bodies in the right jurisdiction and narrowly wins nomination.

2) Two candidates, hard fought nominating campaign for a House of Delegates nomination.  Questionable conduct and fancy footwork on the meeting notice and site by a chairman on the payroll of Candidate A.  Room packed with folks.  Candidate A has more bodies, but Candidate B has questions about are they properly qualified.  Candidate A wins with the help of Chairman, who then disallows Candidate B’s appeals.  Candidate A wins nomination.

Does any of this sound familiar? 

Door #1 is Virginia HOD 50, where Jackson Miller defeated Carroll Weimer for the nomination in 2006, and defeated democrat Jeanette Rishell in the 2006 special election (and again in the 2007 regular election).  GOP Seat held

Door #2 is Virginia HOD 51, where Faisal Gill defeated Julie Lucas in circumstances so poisonous that the repercussions not only severely damaged Gill (who lost his election, and with it a GOP held seat) but also apparently contributed to losing Jay O’Brien’s senate seat. GOP Seat(s) Lost

Mass Meetings are a way to make sure the nomination is not impacted by crossover voting and effectively keeps democrats out of the GOP nominating process.  However, improper machinations can both keep out democrats and disenfranchise GOP voters who want to participate-and that’s even before the meeting begins and matters like slating kick in!

Everyone is tired after the Tuesday elections, and everyone in the GOP is unhappy with the results…but the road back starts with electing a Republican to succeed Jo Ann Davis, and that requires a united party unriven by internal bickering.  More than that, the body politic needs to find a road back to a higher level of discourse and behavior. 

The road to both begin with the Va-1 special election and nominating process…so please, as you go through the mass meetings and convention, choose the conduct found behind Door #1.  Or, as my mother said:

“Be Nice, and Follow the Rules”


7 thoughts on “Va 1: Mom’s Advice, Shenanigans, and a cautionary tale

  1. Excellent examples. The recent LCRC Convention is probably one of the most poorly planned conventions ever. The Convention Call was severely flawed and had to be re-issued. They touted the fact that it was a record crowd, but only 50% of those registered showed for what turned out to be a nine hour affair. Then afterwards, two candidates who lost filed to run as “Independents” with one winning and one losing in the general. Conventions suck and should be banned by RPV.

  2. That November 3 meeting you cited reminded me of something out of the Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy, where the plans for the highway bypass were described as being in a locked filing cabinet in a disused lavatory at the bottom of a dark, broken stairwell closed behind a door with a sign that said “Beware of the leopard.”

  3. After everything that I have read about last Saturday’s Mass Meeting in Caroline, I am hopeful that the Convention tomorrow will vote to not seat any of Caroline’s delegates. The location sounds shady enough, but beginning the meeting before it was supposed to start is a complete and utter disregard for the integrity of the process.

  4. From the RPV’s “Handbook for Mass Meetings, Conventions and Party Canvasses”:
    “All mass meetings must be held in a public place. Frequently, mass meetings are held in public school auditoriums, council chambers, courtrooms, town halls, civic centers, libraries, etc. A private home is not allowed. A commercial space may be appropriate if it is also used for other public functions (such as a bank auditorium).” A private airplane hangar on someone’s private property seems highly suspect. But starting before the time stated in the Call is just plain wrong.

  5. Pingback: Va 1: So Much for “Be Nice” & Predictions « Renaissance Ruminations

  6. Pingback: Not Robert Wittman! « I’m Surrounded By Idiots

  7. Pingback: Conflict of interest? What’s that? …Seriously? « I’m Surrounded By Idiots

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s