The Gov Joins Marsden in Getting It Wrong

Properly wanting to fill a vacancy in the state’s Wikipedia entry, The Gov has recently come out with a new idea for a Virginia state song.  He wants to select the bluegrass classic “Will the Circle Be Unbroken?”.

Right song, wrong classification. Make it the official state bluegrass song, not the state song.

So, so very wrong. If you are a bluegrass fan, great song. If you are a follower of music that traces the roots of the country, great song. If you want a song that can be played at state events and rouse folks, or at least not depress them…so very, very wrong.

As BVBL says:

It’s a nice, upbeat song about waiting for a hearse to carry away the body of someone’s dead mother.

Shoot, may as well pick “Near My God to Thee” or “Shall We Gather at the River”.

You cannot blame The Gov for trying. Virginia has been without an official song since 1997, and without a playable state song for years prior to that. “Carry Me Back to Old Virginny”, the former state song with its lyrics of a black man waxing nostalgic for “Old Massa”, doesn’t have a lot of supporters. It seems like everyone has offered a solution. Chuck Colgan pushed for “Shenandoah”, which had the fatal flaw of not referring to Virginia at all. My puckish state Senator The Cooch suggested“The Tax Man”. My delegate David Marsden tryed to roll a log for a constituent and proposed “Virginia, Ever Enshrined”, which sounds more like a celebration of getting admitted into Canton or Cooperstown.

Better to roll with the Shad Plank suggestion of “Highway to Hell” to reflect our current transportation issues.

Now I am not one of those moaning wombats who complains about a situation and fails to offer solutions. I have before and shall again suggest there is an obvious choice. It is a song that is about Virginia, and has the organic benefit that it was written simply to be written, and not for the sole purpose of becoming the state song. As a matter of fact, I will suggest two songs.

The first, and I think the obvious choice, is “Sweet Virginia Breeze” as I argued here. I will not completely repeat my eloquent exposition here, but as I said almost a year ago:

I admit a sentimental attachment to the song…but I know whether played at the normal pace or at a more stately rate it captures the spirit of those of live in and love Virginia…

…This song is not just entertaining, easy to sing, and fun, it is a real song. It was written to be sung and performed just for the sake of doing it, and not created out of whole cloth for the sole purpose of being submitted as the state song. I like the idea of a song that has had people on their feet dancing and singing and not a prim recital piece that would not exist but for someone wanting their little piece of immortality. So, Delegate Marsden, after the pretenders flame out, put up the real thing. Made in Virginia, vibrant for years, guaranteed to please-”Sweet Virginia Breeze”.

I think that captures the situation quite nicely.

So to The Gov, The Cooch, The Colgan, and The Marsden…jump on the bandwagon, and pick the only possible and reasonable choice for the new state song.  Written as a song, written about Virginia, popular and vibrant for going on two generations.  You know it, you love it, you feel it…


…should be the new state song.

Have a great weekend!


3 thoughts on “The Gov Joins Marsden in Getting It Wrong

  1. Bwana:
    I believe that Del. Marsden and Gov. Tim are suffering from a lack of sufficient oxygen to the brain. At this point, both should leave it alone.
    As far as “Sweet Virginia Breeze” is concerned, well it is definately the best of those suggested so far. Have a great weekend!!

    Bwana Fan In Vienna

  2. Because by common assent of the legislature it has been retired from public use and performance representing the state, and we need a new one in its place.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s